You just barely got there. I was in Waverly Bay for seven months, the timeline fits. Then I made the wish and ended up here - maybe, maybe you just don't remember it yet.
[ He needs this truth more than he's needed anything else. Her hand touches his cheek and he feels a sharp drop in the pit of his stomach her words hitting home. ]
no subject
[ He's sure of it. It has to be. ]
You just barely got there. I was in Waverly Bay for seven months, the timeline fits. Then I made the wish and ended up here - maybe, maybe you just don't remember it yet.
[ He needs this truth more than he's needed anything else. Her hand touches his cheek and he feels a sharp drop in the pit of his stomach her words hitting home. ]
... No. You shouldn't be.